I'd like to play
for an Italian club
... like Barcelona
Mark Draper
 
        
 

   First Phase - Fight 4

 Eamon "The Poison Pencil" Dunphy v John "No Nonsense" Giles

Dunphy is a newcomer to the Wars, having spent the past decade-and-a-half adamantly refusing to take part in it. "Commentator Wars is a hollow sham," he wrote in a 1987 Sunday Independent article. "I will not mince my words - it is a theatre for shameless, sub-standard lethal combat between men who are clearly past it. Only one or two combatants rise above the pathetically low standard that is the norm. John Giles is one. Ron Atkinson is another. In my opinion, these great men should form their own breakaway Commentator Wars federation. Now that, my friends, would be something I could see myself being part of." His industrially sharpened Poison Pencil proved lethal against Morrissey. It was the prospect of easy pickings against this RTE minnow that tempted him into the Pit.

John Giles has been the most successful participant in the Wars since its foundation in the late '60s. He's won the title no fewer than eleven times, and is the current title holder. Giles' modus operandi has changed little since his Leeds days. While other combatants generally carry weapons with them into the Pit, Giles carries a leather 1970's FIFA regulation football. He rolls it towards his opponent, and then follows through in classic over-the-top style to break, sever, or amputate one or both of his opponent's legs.

Cheer on your man!
Vote now to give your favourite the edge!

Do your bit for Dunphy!
Give your all for Giles!!


Current Results

Diamond John Says

Dunphy may be a Wars newcomer at the age of 50-odd, but he's a tricky customer. Even without the Poison Pencil, he can cause a bloodbath. He's bad enough in normal circumstances, but don't get him angry. You wouldn't like him when he's angry. Good value for a wager. 

Verdict. Get in there now. If he gets past Giles, watch his odds plummet.

Tournament odds  6/1


Diamond John Says

Giles' only rival for the moniker Toughest Nut in the entire Wars is Big Ron. Anybody who saw what Giles did to David Icke in the first round in 1992 would have to be mad to get into the Pit with him. But then, everyone in the Wars is mad in one way or another, so Giles still has no trouble finding opponents. 

Verdict.
Tournament favourite, but you'll only get short odds.

Tournament odds
 
2/1 fav

Click here to return to the Commentator Wars Introduction